The New Year can be a good time to evaluate whether you car insurance company can go the extra mile if you run into trouble.
We evaluated insurers to find the best car insurance companies based on average car insurance rates, levels of complaints and grades for collision claims from auto body repair professionals provided by CRASH Network.
- Erie Insurance
- USAA
- State Farm
- Travelers
- Auto-Owners Insurance
- Geico
- Nationwide
Car Insurance Company Ratings Summary
| Company | Auto insurance rates | Collision repair grade | Complaint level |
| Erie | Very good | A- | Higher than the industry average |
| USAA | Excellent | C+ | OK |
| State Farm | Very Good | C | Low |
| Travelers | Good | C+ | Very Low |
| Auto-Owners | OK | B+ | Low |
| Geico | Good | C- | Low |
| Nationwide | OK | C | Very Low |
| Allstate | Poor | C- | Low |
| Progressive | OK | C | OK |
| Farmers | Poor | C | Higher than the industry average |